Estimate the rehab before you make the offer.

The repair number is the one figure in a deal you control, and the one most investors guess. This is the complete method: walk it, scope it, price it, add what gets forgotten, then work back to the most you can pay.

By Jerryll NoordenNovember 20, 202612 min read
Out loud, about 6 minutes. Ask him anything.

The short version

  • Your offer is only as good as your repair number. A $10,000 miss on repairs is a $10,000 miss on profit.
  • Walk every room with a camera and write the scope as items with quantities, not "needs work".
  • Price at the finish level of your exit: rental-grade for a rental, retail-ready for a flip.
  • Add the costs that get forgotten: permits, dumpsters, consumables and a contingency for what you couldn't see.
  • Then work back from the after repair value: repairs, buying and selling costs, holding, financing, your profit or fee.

Why the repair number decides the deal.

The after repair value is set by the market. Your buying and selling costs are set by the market. The repair number is the one you make yourself, and it comes straight out of your profit when it is wrong. Underestimate by $10,000 and a $25,000 flip becomes a $15,000 flip. Overestimate by $10,000 and you lose the deal to someone who didn't.

Most investors estimate repairs with a rule of thumb, a price per square foot, or a quick walk and a gut feeling. That works on easy houses. It fails on the ones with a soft floor, an old roof or a kitchen that is "fine" until you price it.

$1 for $1every repair dollar you miss comes out of your profit
70%the classic rule of thumb: ARV × 0.7 minus repairsCommon investor formula
1 walkthroughwhat a real repair number needs

Step 1: walk it with a camera.

Go room by room, the same order every time, so nothing gets skipped: exterior and roof, kitchen, bathrooms, bedrooms and living areas, then the systems (electrical panel, water heater, furnace, plumbing under sinks). Photograph each room from the doorway and each problem up close. Note the size of each room or measure it.

Photos are your second walkthrough. At the desk you will wonder whether the vanity was 30 or 36 inches, or whether that stain was on the ceiling or the wall. The photo answers it without driving back. EstiMate turns the photos into scope lines and measures the quantities as you take them.

Step 2: write the scope as items.

"Kitchen needs work" can't be priced. "Replace 14 linear feet of base and upper cabinets, laminate counter, sink and faucet, 160 sq ft LVP" can. Write every room as items with quantities, and pick the finish level that matches your exit.

Finish levelForExample kitchen
Rental-gradeBuy and holdPaint cabinets, laminate, new hardware
Retail-readyFlips, mid-marketStock shaker cabinets, quartz, LVP
High-endFlips in upper neighborhoodsSemi-custom, quartz, tile backsplash

Step 3: price it, and add what gets forgotten.

Price each item with real local numbers: your contractors' prices if you have them, a cost book if you don't. Then add the costs that are easy to miss because they don't belong to a room: the dumpster, permits, consumables, and a contingency. On older houses a 10 percent contingency for what you couldn't see is common sense, not pessimism.

A 3-bed, 1.5-bath flipRepairs
Kitchen: stock cabinets, quartz, sink, faucet$9,800
Full bath refresh: vanity, toilet, tub surround$4,200
LVP flooring, 1,100 sq ft$4,950
Interior paint, walls and trim$3,900
Roof repair and flashing$1,400
Water heater and furnace service$1,650
Electrical and plumbing fixes$1,050
Dumpster, permits, consumables$1,500
Total repairs$28,450

Step 4: work back to your offer.

Now start from the after repair value, the price the house sells for once fixed, and subtract everything that has to come out of it. What is left is the most you can pay.

Working back from ARVAmount
After repair value$285,000
− Repairs$28,450
− Selling: commissions and closing$17,100
− Buying: closing costs$2,450
− Holding: taxes, insurance, utilities, 4 months$3,200
− Financing$3,800
− Wholesale fee$12,000
− Buyer's profit$40,550
Maximum offer$177,450

For comparison, the 70 percent rule gives $285,000 × 0.7 − $28,450 = $171,050. The rule is a good screen; the itemized number is the one to negotiate with, because you know what every dollar is for.

Where the after repair value goes

Maximum offer$177,450
Buyer's profit$40,550
Repairs$28,450
Buying, selling, holding, financing$26,550
Wholesale fee$12,000

Step 5: check it before you offer.

  1. 1

    Sanity-check per square foot

    Divide repairs by living area and compare with your last few houses. A big gap means something was missed or doubled.

  2. 2

    Look at the big three

    Roof, foundation and systems cause the largest surprises. If any of them is uncertain, carry an allowance.

  3. 3

    Get a contractor's eye

    Send the scope to a contractor or two for a quick price. With a written scope and photos they can do it from the desk.

  4. 4

    Keep the scope

    Once you own the house, the same scope becomes your bid package and your budget to track against.

Doing it in one walkthrough.

EstiMate does the whole sequence from your phone. Walk the house and take photos; it writes the scope, measures quantities and prices every line at the finish level you choose, with permits, dumpsters and consumables added. The deal analysis then works back from the after repair value to your maximum offer, with flip, rental and wholesale views side by side. Send the scope to contractors from the same screen and their prices come back line by line.

Questions

What people ask first.

How do I estimate rehab costs without a contractor?

Walk every room with photos, write the scope as items with quantities, price each item with local costs, and add permits, dumpsters, consumables and a contingency.

Is the 70 percent rule accurate?

It is a useful quick screen. Your real maximum offer should come from itemized costs: repairs, buying, selling, holding, financing and your profit or fee.

How much contingency should I add?

Ten percent is common on older houses. Use more when the roof, foundation or systems are uncertain.

What is a maximum allowable offer?

The most you can pay for a house and still make your target profit after every cost of fixing and selling it.

Should a rental be estimated differently from a flip?

Yes. Price a rental at durable rental-grade finishes and a flip at the finish level buyers in that neighborhood expect.

JN
Jerryll NoordenFounder of REILink. Former NASA robotic scientist, flipping houses since 2016. He built EstiMate because every repair number he was handed was a guess.

Know the repairs. Make the offer.

A full scope and repair number from one walkthrough, and the most you can pay, before the seller signs with someone else.

Free for a week. The week starts on your first property, not the day you sign up.