The costs your estimate forgets.

Thinset, tape, blades, the dumpster, the dump fee, the permit. None of them is big. Together they are often the whole difference between the margin you bid and the margin you keep.

By Jerryll NoordenNovember 20, 20268 min read
Out loud, about 4 minutes. Ask him anything.

The short version

  • Small items, site costs and general conditions often add up to 5 to 15 percent of job cost.
  • They go missing because nobody writes them down: they are too small to think about and too obvious to list.
  • A 20-yard dumpster alone typically rents for $300 to $700 a week, before the weight is over the limit.
  • Half of contractors in one survey left general conditions, such as supervision and temporary power, out of their estimates.
  • The fix is to attach each supply to the item that uses it, so it is priced every time, automatically.

Where the money goes missing.

An estimate is built from the work you can point at: cabinets, tile, a vanity, a circuit. The costs that go missing are the ones you can't point at. They fall into three groups.

  1. 1

    Consumables

    The supplies each item eats while it is installed: thinset, grout, caulk, tape, plastic, adhesive, fasteners, shims, saw blades and drill bits.

  2. 2

    Site costs

    What the job needs no matter what is installed: dumpsters and dump fees, permits, floor and wall protection, temporary power, a portable toilet.

  3. 3

    General conditions

    The time around the work: supervision, trips to the supplier, phone calls, cleanup, the final punch list.

Each of them is small enough to skip on a single job without noticing. That is exactly the problem: they are skipped on every job.

How much it really is.

The size of the gap surprises most contractors the first time they add it up. Contractor guides commonly put small items at 5 to 15 percent of job cost. A survey by Intuit of more than 500 contractors found that half of them left general conditions out of their estimates entirely. And dumpster pricing guides from HomeAdvisor and Angi put a typical 20-yard roll-off, the size most remodels use, at roughly $300 to $700 a week, with landfill fees of around $20 to $50 a ton when you go over the weight included.

5–15%of job cost in small items and site costsContractor estimating guides
50%of contractors leave general conditions outIntuit survey, 500+ contractors
$300–$700a week for a 20-yard dumpsterHomeAdvisor and Angi cost guides

On a $20,000 job, 7 percent is $1,400. If your margin was 20 percent, that is a third of it.

A kitchen, priced twice.

Here is the same kitchen remodel priced the usual way, then again with what the job really uses. Every line in the second column is something the crew will buy or pay for whether or not it is in the price.

Kitchen remodelPriced by handWith what it really uses
Cabinets, installed$9,800$9,800
Quartz countertops$4,200$4,200
Tile backsplash, 30 sq ft$1,050$1,050
LVP flooring, 180 sq ft$2,340$2,340
Plumbing: sink, faucet, dishwasher$1,100$1,100
Electrical: under-cabinet lights, circuits$1,450$1,450
Paint, walls and ceiling$780$780
Thinset, grout, sealer—$54
Underlayment and transitions—$310
Tape, plastic, drop cloths—$95
Fasteners, shims, adhesive—$120
Caulk and sealants—$48
Blades and bits—$65
Floor and counter protection—$140
20-yard dumpster, one week—$520
Electrical permit—$180
Total cost$20,720$22,252

That is $1,532, or 7.4 percent of the job, that the first price never covered. Put a 25 percent markup on the first column and you bid $25,900, thinking you will gross $5,180. You will gross $3,648. Why markup hides this is its own story.

Why a percentage doesn't fix it.

The common shortcut is to add a flat percentage for "misc." It is better than nothing and it is still wrong, because these costs don't follow the job total. They follow the work.

A $12,000 cabinet order uses a box of screws. A $1,050 tile backsplash uses thinset, grout, sealer, spacers, a blade and a day of cleanup. Demolition fills a dumpster whether the new finishes are cheap or expensive. A flat percentage overcharges the cabinet-heavy job, which makes you lose it to someone cheaper, and undercharges the tile-heavy job, which you win and lose money on.

Supplies as a share of each item

Cabinets, installedabout 1%
Flooring with underlaymentabout 13%
Tile backsplashabout 10%
Paintingabout 12%

How to price them every time.

The reliable method is to attach the supplies to the items that use them, once, and let them come along every time that item is used.

  1. 1

    List the supplies per item

    For each line in your price list, write what it eats: tile gets thinset, grout and sealer per square foot; paint gets tape and plastic per room.

  2. 2

    Use your real prices

    Price each supply at what you pay your supplier, including the delivery or the trip to pick it up.

  3. 3

    Add the site costs by trigger

    Demolition triggers a dumpster. A new circuit triggers an electrical permit. A floor triggers protection for the rooms next to it.

  4. 4

    Add general conditions as time

    Supervision, supplier runs and the punch list are hours. Price them as hours at your rate, scaled to the length of the job.

  5. 5

    Check the total against history

    Compare what you priced with what the last few jobs really cost. If supplies still run over, the list is missing something.

Letting EstiMate remember for you.

In EstiMate every item in your price list carries its own consumables. When a photo of the walkthrough turns into "tile backsplash, 30 square feet", the thinset, grout and sealer come with it, at your prices, in the right quantity. Demolition adds the dumpster sized to the debris, and work that needs a permit adds the permit for your area.

Nothing is hidden from the client either. Supplies can show as their own lines or roll into the item they belong to, so the proposal reads cleanly while the cost is still covered.

The point isn't to charge more. It is to charge for what the job actually uses, so the price you win at is the price you make money at.

Questions

What people ask first.

What counts as a consumable in construction?

Anything used up while installing the work and not left as a finished item: adhesives, thinset, grout, caulk, tape, plastic, fasteners, shims, blades and bits.

How much should I budget for small items?

Price them per item when you can. As a check, small items and site costs often come to 5 to 15 percent of job cost, depending on the trades involved.

Should dumpsters and permits be separate lines?

Yes. They are triggered by specific work, so pricing them as their own lines makes them easy to explain and impossible to forget.

What are general conditions?

The costs of running the job rather than doing the work: supervision, supplier trips, phone calls, cleanup and the punch list.

Will showing these costs scare clients?

Clients react to surprises, not to detail. A clear line for the dumpster and the permit is easier to accept than a change order for them later.

JN
Jerryll NoordenFounder of REILink. Former NASA robotic scientist, flipping houses since 2016. He built EstiMate because every repair number he was handed was a guess.

Charge for what the job uses.

Every supply attached to the work that uses it, every dumpster and permit added by the work that needs it, at your prices.

Free for a week. The week starts on your first property, not the day you sign up.