Markup vs margin: why 20% isn't 20%.

Markup is a percentage of what the job costs you. Margin is a percentage of what the client pays. Mixing them up is one of the quietest ways a busy contractor ends the year with less than they planned.

By Jerryll NoordenNovember 20, 20266 min read
Out loud, about 3 minutes. Ask him anything.

The short version

  • Markup = profit divided by cost. Margin = profit divided by price. Same dollars, different percentages.
  • A 25 percent markup is a 20 percent margin. A 50 percent markup is a 33 percent margin.
  • NAHB's latest study puts the average remodeler at a 29.9 percent gross margin, of which 23.6 points go to running the business.
  • To earn a 30 percent gross margin you need a markup of about 43 percent, not 30.
  • Work out the margin you need first, then convert it to a markup. Never the other way around.

The same dollars, two percentages.

Say a job costs you $10,000 and you sell it for $12,500. You made $2,500. As a markup that is 25 percent, because $2,500 is a quarter of your cost. As a margin it is 20 percent, because $2,500 is a fifth of the price.

Both numbers are true. The trouble starts when you set prices in one and think in the other. Most contractors set prices with markup, because it is easy: cost times 1.25. But overhead, profit goals and industry benchmarks are all quoted as margin, a share of revenue. Compare the two directly and you overestimate your profit every time.

One job, one profit, two ways to describe it.

The two formulas you need.

You only need two conversions, and they are worth keeping on a sticky note.

  1. 1

    Margin from markup

    Margin = markup ÷ (1 + markup). A 25% markup: 0.25 ÷ 1.25 = 20% margin.

  2. 2

    Markup from margin

    Markup = margin ÷ (1 − margin). A 30% margin: 0.30 ÷ 0.70 = 42.9% markup.

Markup on costMargin on pricePrice on a $10,000 cost
10%9.1%$11,000
20%16.7%$12,000
25%20.0%$12,500
33%25.0%$13,333
43%30.1%$14,300
50%33.3%$15,000
67%40.1%$16,700
100%50.0%$20,000

What remodelers actually earn.

The National Association of Home Builders surveys remodelers' finances every few years. In its 2026 edition, covering 2024, the average remodeler spent 70.1 percent of revenue on the cost of the work, leaving a gross margin of 29.9 percent. Running the business, including overhead and the owner's pay, took another 23.6 percent of revenue. What was left, the net profit, was 6.3 percent, the best in nearly thirty years.

29.9%average gross margin for remodelers in 2024NAHB Remodelers' Cost of Doing Business Study, 2026
23.6%of revenue spent running the businessNAHB, 2026 edition
6.3%average net profit, the highest since 1996NAHB, 2026 edition

Look at that gross margin as a markup and it is about 43 percent. A contractor marking up 25 percent and believing they are "in line with the industry" is actually ten points of margin below it.

What a 25% markup really does.

Take a $20,000 job and a business whose overhead runs 23.6 percent of revenue, the NAHB average. Here is the same job at two markups.

On a $20,000 job cost25% markup43% markup
Price to client$25,000$28,600
Gross profit$5,000$8,600
Gross margin20.0%30.1%
Overhead at 23.6% of revenue$5,900$6,750
Net profit−$900$1,850

The 25 percent job looks fine on the estimate and loses $900 once the business has been paid for. That is how a busy year with plenty of work ends with nothing in the bank.

Forgotten costs make it worse. If the estimate also missed consumables and dumpster fees, the gross profit was smaller than $5,000 before overhead was even counted. Here is where those go.

How to set your markup.

Start from the margin, because margin is what your business runs on.

  1. 1

    Find your overhead as a share of revenue

    Add up last year's truck, insurance, office, software, marketing and your own salary, and divide by last year's revenue.

  2. 2

    Choose the net profit you want

    Something you could live with in a slow year. Ten percent is a common target; the industry average is lower.

  3. 3

    Add them for your target gross margin

    Overhead 22% plus net 10% means you need a 32% gross margin.

  4. 4

    Convert it to a markup

    0.32 ÷ 0.68 = 47%. That is the markup to put on job cost.

  5. 5

    Adjust by job size

    Small jobs carry the same trips and calls as big ones. Many contractors use a higher markup or a minimum charge on small work.

Building it into every estimate.

In EstiMate the markup lives in your settings and on each item, so every estimate is priced from the same rule. The estimate shows cost, markup and the resulting margin side by side, so you can see the margin before the client sees the price, and a job below your target is flagged before you send it.

Clients see the price, by room and by finish level. Your markup stays yours.

Questions

What people ask first.

Is markup or margin better for pricing?

Use whichever you like to set the price, but measure the result as margin, because overhead and profit goals are shares of revenue.

What markup gives a 30 percent margin?

About 42.9 percent: 0.30 ÷ 0.70.

What is a typical remodeling markup?

It varies by business, but the NAHB average gross margin of 29.9 percent corresponds to a markup of about 43 percent.

Why do I make less than my markup?

Because markup is measured on cost and your overhead is measured on revenue. A 25 percent markup is a 20 percent margin, and overhead comes out of that.

Should subcontractor costs get the same markup?

Most contractors mark up subcontracted work too, because it still uses your supervision, scheduling and warranty. Some use a slightly lower markup on large sub packages.

JN
Jerryll NoordenFounder of REILink. Former NASA robotic scientist, flipping houses since 2016. He built EstiMate because every repair number he was handed was a guess.

Know your margin before you send.

Your markup on every item, the margin it really makes on every job, visible before the price ever reaches the client.

Free for a week. The week starts on your first property, not the day you sign up.