Why bids for the same job differ by 100%.

Three contractors walk the same house and come back with $22,000, $31,000 and $44,000. Usually nobody is lying. They priced three different jobs, and the bids don't say so.

By Jerryll NoordenNovember 20, 20267 min read
Out loud, about 4 minutes. Ask him anything.

The short version

  • Wide spreads are normal when each contractor writes their own scope: different items, different finishes, different assumptions.
  • The biggest causes: missing line items, finish level, allowances, permits and cleanup, and the contractor's own business model.
  • The lowest total is often the one with the most left out, which comes back later as change orders.
  • To compare bids, every contractor must price the same scope, line by line, at the same finish level.
  • Then the spread shrinks to what it really is, and the differences are items you can ask about.

Three bids, three different jobs.

Here is what is often behind a spread like that. Each bid is honest for the job its contractor had in mind. They just didn't have the same job in mind.

What each bid includes$22,000$31,000$44,000
KitchenPaint cabinets, laminate topNew stock cabinets, quartzSemi-custom, quartz, tile
BathroomReglaze tub, new vanityNew tub surround, vanityFull gut, tiled shower
FlooringLVP in living areas onlyLVP throughoutLVP, tile in wet areas
PermitsNot mentionedIncludedIncluded
Dumpster and cleanupNot mentionedIncludedIncluded
Hidden conditionsNot mentioned$1,500 allowance$4,000 allowance

The $22,000 bid isn't cheap; it is small. Once the permit, the dumpster and the subfloor nobody mentioned show up, it may not be the cheapest at all.

The five reasons bids drift apart.

  1. 1

    Different scope

    Each contractor decides what "fix the kitchen" means. One refreshes, one replaces.

  2. 2

    Different finish level

    Laminate versus quartz, stock versus semi-custom. Finishes can double a room's price on their own.

  3. 3

    Missing line items

    Permits, dumpsters, protection, cleanup and consumables are in some bids and silently absent from others.

  4. 4

    Allowances and assumptions

    What happens if the subfloor is rotten? One bid prices it, one excludes it, one doesn't say.

  5. 5

    The business behind the bid

    A one-truck operator and a firm with a project manager, insurance and a warranty have different overhead, and it shows in the price.

Only the last one is a real price difference. The first four are differences in what you are buying.

The trouble with the lowest bid.

The lowest bid is attractive and often the most incomplete. Whatever it left out still has to be done, and it comes back as change orders once the walls are open, when you have the least leverage. A bid that excluded the permit, the dumpster and a hidden-conditions allowance can easily grow by 10 to 20 percent before the job is done.

What the low bid may really cost

Low bid as written$22,000
+ permit, dumpster, cleanup$23,400
+ subfloor found at demolition$25,200
This isn't an argument for the highest bid. It is an argument for comparing the same job. Once everyone prices the same scope, the low bid may genuinely be the best one.

How to get bids you can compare.

  1. 1

    Write the scope first

    Room by room, item by item, with quantities. This is what you are asking them to price.

  2. 2

    Set the finish level

    Say it plainly: rental-grade, mid-range or high-end, with examples of the materials.

  3. 3

    Ask for line items

    A price per item or per room, not one total. Totals hide everything that matters.

  4. 4

    Ask the same questions

    Is the permit included? The dumpster? Cleanup? What is the allowance for hidden conditions?

  5. 5

    Line them up

    Put the bids side by side by line. The items that differ most are the ones to ask about.

Reading bids side by side.

When three contractors price the same scope, the spread usually narrows to something like 10 to 15 percent, and the differences become specific. One is high on tile, one is low on paint, one includes a longer warranty. Those are conversations you can have.

Same scope, three bidsRidgelineBluepointHarbor
Kitchen$14,950$13,820$15,400
Bathroom$7,300$6,980$7,640
Flooring$9,120$8,760$9,900
Paint and trim$6,412$6,050$7,110
Roof and exterior$8,600$8,300$8,950
Total$46,382$43,910$49,000

Here the spread is $5,090, about 12 percent, and you can see where it comes from: Harbor is higher on every room, not hiding anything. That is a real choice between real prices.

Doing it without the legwork.

EstiMate builds the scope for you from a walkthrough: rooms, items, quantities, photos and a finish level. Send it to the contractors you choose. Contractors on EstiMate price it with their own prices; others fill in a bid form with the same items. Every bid comes back against the same lines, and EstiMate lays them side by side so the differences are the first thing you see.

Questions

What people ask first.

Is a 100 percent difference between bids normal?

It is common when each contractor writes their own scope. When they all price the same scope, the gap usually shrinks a lot.

Should I take the lowest bid?

Only after checking it includes the same items as the others. The lowest total is often the most incomplete.

What is an allowance in a bid?

A set amount for something that can't be priced yet, such as hidden damage or a fixture you haven't chosen. If the real cost is different, the price adjusts.

How many bids should I get?

Three is a good number, as long as they price the same scope. More bids on different scopes just adds confusion.

Why do contractors refuse to itemize?

Some worry it invites haggling line by line. Asking for prices by room is a reasonable middle ground.

JN
Jerryll NoordenFounder of REILink. Former NASA robotic scientist, flipping houses since 2016. He built EstiMate because every repair number he was handed was a guess.

Same scope. Real comparison.

One scope from your walkthrough, priced by every contractor line by line, laid side by side so the differences are clear.

Free for a week. The week starts on your first property, not the day you sign up.