From inspection report to repair credit.
A 40-page report with sixty items is not a negotiation. A short list of the items that matter, each priced and photographed, is. Here is how to get from one to the other in an afternoon.
The short version
- Sort every finding into four groups: safety, structure, systems that don't work, and everything cosmetic.
- Only the first three belong in a repair request. Asking for cosmetic items is the fastest way to stall a deal.
- Price each item that remains, with the inspector's photo attached.
- Choose repair or credit: a credit is often faster and lets the buyer control the work.
- If the buyer is financing, the lender usually needs written estimates to approve a credit.
Step 1: sort the report into four groups.
Inspectors write down everything, which is their job. Your job is to separate what matters from what doesn't. Go through the summary and put every item in one of four groups.
- 1
Safety
Electrical hazards, missing GFCI protection, gas or carbon monoxide concerns, missing handrails.
- 2
Structure and water
Roof leaks, flashing, foundation movement, grading that sends water toward the house.
- 3
Systems that don't work
A failing water heater, a furnace with a cracked flue, active plumbing leaks.
- 4
Cosmetic and maintenance
Worn paint, a sticking door, dated fixtures, normal wear. Noted, not negotiated.
Most buyer's guides from lenders and brokerages give the same advice: focus requests on safety, structure and systems, not cosmetics or normal wear.
Step 2: price what remains.
For each item in the first three groups, write what the fix is and what it costs. Use the inspector's description, the photo and the quantities: "replace 40-gallon gas water heater", not "water heater old".
| Example inspection findings | Repair | Cost |
|---|---|---|
| Roof: lifted flashing at chimney, two damaged areas | Re-flash, replace shingles | $950 |
| Water heater: 14 years, rust at base | Replace 40-gal gas unit | $1,850 |
| Electrical: no GFCI in kitchen and bath, double-tapped breaker | Add GFCIs, correct panel | $780 |
| Furnace: cracked flue pipe | Service, replace flue section | $620 |
| Deck: ledger without flashing, loose handrail | Flash ledger, secure rail | $1,150 |
| Gutters and grading toward foundation | Extend downspouts, regrade | $560 |
| Plumbing: leaking trap, slow drain | Replace trap, clear line | $340 |
| Bath fan vents into attic | Vent to exterior | $600 |
| Repair credit requested | $6,850 |
Step 3: attach the evidence.
Each line should carry the photo from the report and the page it came from. The other side's first reaction to a number is "that seems high". A photo of the rusted water heater base and a line saying what replacement involves answers it before it is asked.
Keep the language neutral: what the inspector found, what fixes it, what it costs. Avoid adjectives. Numbers with evidence are hard to argue with; opinions are easy to.
Step 4: repair or credit?
| Seller repairs | Credit at closing | |
|---|---|---|
| Who controls the work | Seller's contractor | Buyer, after closing |
| Speed | Needs scheduling before closing | Settled on paper |
| Quality risk | Buyer must check the work | Buyer chooses the contractor |
| Lender | Usually wants proof of completion | Must approve the credit, often wants estimates |
| Best for | Safety items a lender requires fixed | Most other items |
Credits often keep a deal moving because nobody has to schedule a contractor before closing. Some items, especially safety issues a lender or insurer flags, may have to be repaired regardless.
Step 5: send it as one clear request.
- 1
One page summary
The items, the fixes and the total, at the top.
- 2
Line detail behind it
Each item with its photo and report reference.
- 3
The ask
A specific credit amount, or the specific repairs, by a specific date.
- 4
Room to agree
If you expect a counter, know in advance which items your client cares most about.
Doing it in EstiMate.
Upload the inspection report or walk the problem areas with your phone. EstiMate turns the findings into priced repair lines with the photos attached, lets you leave out what is cosmetic, and produces a one-page credit request with the detail behind it. Share it with the other agent or the lender through a link, branded as yours.
What people ask first.
What repairs are reasonable to ask for after an inspection?
Safety hazards, structural and water issues, and major systems that don't work. Cosmetic items and normal wear usually aren't.
Is a repair credit better than repairs?
Often, because it settles the issue on paper and lets the buyer choose the contractor. Items a lender requires fixed may still need to be repaired before closing.
How do you calculate a repair credit?
Price each item that matters with local repair costs, total them, and attach the photos and report references as support.
Do lenders need estimates for a repair credit?
Lenders usually must approve a seller credit, and many ask for written estimates or invoices behind it.
How many items should a repair request include?
As few as cover what really matters. A short, priced list is more likely to be accepted than a long one.
Read next.
How Real Estate Agents Use Repair Estimates to Win Listings and Save Deals
Buyers guess high, sellers won't fix, inspections drag. A real repair number at the showing, the listing appointment and the inspection changes all three.
9 min readWhat Should It Cost to Fix? How to Know a Fair Repair Price Before You Call Anyone
Why quotes for the same repair vary so much, what goes into a fair price, when to do it yourself, and how to walk into every conversation knowing the number.
9 min readWhy Contractor Bids Vary by 100% for the Same Job (and How to Compare Them)
Different scopes, different finish levels, missing line items and different business models. How to get bids you can actually compare, line by line.
7 min readA priced list, not a long report.
The findings that matter, priced, photographed and on one page, so the deal keeps moving.
Free for a week. The week starts on your first property, not the day you sign up.
Hi, I'm Humphrey.
I'll read this article to you, part by part. Stop me and ask anything along the way.
Can't hear me? Make sure your speakers are on